Court Disqualifies Expert in Seaman’s Suit: Mechanical Engineer Unqualified to Opine on Vessel Operation

Bunting v. Odyssea Marine, Inc., 2024 WL 1991488, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 82043 * (E.D. La., May 6, 2024, Ashe, J.).

            Damon Bunting was hired by Odyssea Marine to serve as captain on M/V ODYSSEA TITAN, an offshore supply vessel.[1] While off duty in his bunk, he was awakened bouncing up and down.[2] He found out that the first mate positioned the vessel with its stern into the waves.[3] He filed a Jones Act suit also claiming unseaworthiness of the vessel and negligence under General Maritime law seeking damages for alleged injury to his “back, leg, knees and feet.”[4]

            To bolster the negligence claim, Bunting hired G. Fred Liebkemann, IV, a mechanical engineer, as a “liability expert” to opine about the design, construction and operation of the vessel as well as ballasting of the vessel.[5] He concluded that the vessel was lightly loaded leading to the claimed accident.[6]

            Odeyssea filed a Motion in Limine to exclude Liebkemann’s testimony on the basis that his opinions are outside the field of his expertise of mechanical engineering.[7]

            Judge Ashe granted the Motion on the basis that Liebekmann has no qualifications in the fields of “naval architecture, marine engineering, and vessel operations”[8] and that his opinion that Bunting did not contribute to the accident “is a legal conclusion and does not fall within the province of an expert.”[9] While he may have experience in crane operations, the case is about vessel operation and handling not crane operation.[10]

[1] Bunting, 2024 WL 1991488 at *1.

[2] Id.

[3] Id.

[4] Id.

[5] Id. at *2; Liebkemann outlined 6 opinions.

[6] Id. at *1

[7] Id. at *2

[8] Id. at *4

[9] Id.

[10] Id.

The Current Loyola Maritime Law Journal

The Current is the blog of the Loyola New Orleans Maritime Law Journal, where we post updates to keep our readers up to date about new decisions in maritime law. We also post news about the Journal and its' members.

Previous
Previous

No Jury Trial in Counterclaim in Breach of Contract Suit Despite OSCLA Jurisdiction

Next
Next

Court Awards $3,761,500.00 in Salvage Award; Salvage Convention Factors Applied